This is the third in an 8-part series reflecting on the International Year of Quantum’s guiding principles.

Embracing the Third Principle of the International Year of Quantum

As the world celebrates the International Year of Quantum Science and Technology (IYQ) in 2025, marking the centennial of Werner Heisenberg's groundbreaking formulation of quantum mechanics, we find ourselves standing at a fascinating crossroads between scientific legacy and future potential. Among the guiding principles that shape this global initiative, the third principle — "Recognize Consensus, Honor Dissent, and Admit Ignorance" —emerges as perhaps the most profound reflection of not just quantum science itself, but of the scientific endeavor as a whole.

Quantum Leaps

There is something deliciously appropriate about applying this principle to quantum science—a field that has, from its inception, challenged our most fundamental assumptions about reality. Just as quantum particles exist in states of superposition until measured, our understanding of quantum phenomena exists in a perpetual dance between what we collectively agree upon, what remains contested, and the vast expanse of what we have yet to comprehend.

When Heisenberg developed his mathematical formulation of quantum mechanics in 1925, focusing solely on observable relationships rather than theoretical constructs that could not be measured, he set in motion a transformation in physics that continues to reverberate through our technological landscape a century later. Yet even as quantum mechanics has become one of the most successful scientific theories ever developed — powering everything from the transistors in our computers to MRI machines in hospitals—it remains a realm where consensus, dissent, and acknowledged ignorance coexist in productive tension.

Recognizing Consensus: The Common Ground

Scientific consensus represents the accumulated weight of evidence and theoretical understanding that has survived rigorous scrutiny. In quantum science, there exists robust consensus on the mathematical framework that allows us to make astonishingly accurate predictions about quantum systems. The Standard Model of particle physics, quantum electrodynamics, and the principles of quantum computation all represent areas where sufficient evidence and theoretical coherence have established a common ground for further exploration.

Recognizing consensus is not about declaring absolute truth but about acknowledging the solid foundation upon which we build our expanding understanding. It represents the collaborative achievement of generations of scientists who have contributed to a coherent body of knowledge that works — that makes predictions which align with experimental results to extraordinary precision.

But the spirit of the IYQ's third principle suggests something more nuanced than merely listing established facts. It invites us to recognize consensus as a dynamic, evolving state — one that provides essential stability while remaining open to refinement, extension, and occasional revolution.

Honoring Dissent: The Seeds of Tomorrow

If consensus provides the stable ground of quantum science, dissent offers the fertile soil from which new insights grow. Throughout the history of quantum physics, principled dissent has played a vital role in refining and extending our understanding. From Einstein's famous resistance to quantum indeterminacy ("God does not play dice") to ongoing debates about quantum interpretation, dissent has prevented premature closure of scientific questions.

Honoring dissent means creating space for alternative viewpoints that challenge the mainstream — not out of contrarianism, but out of genuine scientific curiosity and commitment to following evidence wherever it leads. It means acknowledging that today's fringe theory might become tomorrow's new consensus, just as quantum theory itself once occupied the scientific periphery.

In the quantum realm particularly, where multiple interpretations of the same mathematical formalism can lead to identical experimental predictions, honoring dissent acknowledges the philosophical dimensions of scientific inquiry. The Copenhagen, Many-Worlds, Pilot Wave, and other interpretations of quantum mechanics represent not failures of consensus but a rich ecosystem of thought that keeps quantum science intellectually vibrant and philosophically engaged.

Admitting Ignorance: The Wellspring of Discovery

Perhaps the most courageous aspect of the third principle is its explicit embrace of ignorance. In an era where experts often feel pressure to project certainty, admitting the boundaries of our knowledge represents an act of intellectual honesty that ultimately serves scientific progress.

Quantum science abounds with acknowledged unknowns: How do we reconcile quantum mechanics with general relativity? What is the true nature of quantum gravity? How does quantum coherence relate to consciousness? What are the ultimate limits of quantum computing? These questions remain open not because of insufficient effort but because they probe the very frontiers of human understanding.

Admitting ignorance is not an admission of failure but a recognition of opportunity. It maps the fertile territories awaiting exploration and prevents the premature closure of inquiry that can occur when we pretend to know more than we do. Paradoxically, by embracing what we don't know, we open ourselves to discovering what we couldn't previously imagine.

The Third Principle in Practice

As we celebrate the International Year of Quantum in 2025, this third principle offers practical guidance for how we might engage with quantum science and technology:

• For scientists, it suggests a balanced approach that builds upon established knowledge while remaining open to revision, challenges mainstream views constructively, and clearly communicates the boundaries between what is well-established, what remains contentious, and what lies beyond current understanding.
• For educators, it provides a framework for teaching quantum concepts that honors both the power of current models and their inevitable limitations, helping students navigate the tension between mastering established knowledge and cultivating the creativity needed to transcend it.
• For policymakers and industry leaders, it offers a nuanced perspective that can inform decisions about quantum technology investments—encouraging confidence in well-established applications while maintaining appropriate humility about more speculative possibilities.
• For the general public, it presents quantum science not as an intimidating monolith of esoteric certainties, but as an accessible, ongoing human adventure in which everyone can participate through curiosity, questioning, and wonder.

Beyond Quantum: A Principle for Our Time

While particularly resonant for quantum science, "Recognize Consensus, Honor Dissent, and Admit Ignorance" offers wisdom that extends far beyond this specific domain. In an era of polarization where knowledge claims are increasingly weaponized in cultural and political conflicts, this principle offers a middle path—one that values collective knowledge achievement without dogmatism, that respects challenge without cynicism, and that acknowledges limitation without despair.

As we stand at the threshold of quantum technologies that promise to transform computing, communication, medicine, and energy, this principle reminds us that our greatest scientific achievements have always emerged from a delicate balance—between what we collectively affirm, what we productively question, and what we honestly acknowledge we have yet to understand.

In this centennial year of quantum mechanics, as we celebrate the remarkable journey from Heisenberg's mathematical breakthrough to today's quantum technologies, perhaps the most fitting tribute to the quantum pioneers is to embrace this principle fully—recognizing the consensus they helped build, honoring the dissent that refined their insights, and admitting the vast ignorance that still awaits illumination by generations to come.

For in that balanced approach, we don't just honor quantum's past — we create the conditions for its future to flourish in ways we can scarcely yet imagine.

Start Your Quantum Journey with Keysight

Keysight’s strategic collaborations, specialized test and measurement solutions, quantum control systems, and quantum system design software tools are advancing progress in quantum computing research and commercialization. You can tap into expert insights and learn more about the tools driving quantum research forward by exploring Keysight Learn. Challenge yourself by enrolling for expert-led quantum bootcamps or exploring the growing library of quantum resources to expand your knowledge of this dynamic, emerging technology space.

Keysight Technologies

Keysight Technologies

At Keysight (NYSE: KEYS), we inspire and empower innovators to bring world-changing technologies to life. As an S&P 500 company, we’re delivering market-leading design, emulation, and test solutions to help engineers develop and deploy faster, with less risk, throughout the entire product lifecycle. We’re a global innovation partner enabling customers in communications, industrial automation, aerospace and defense, automotive, semiconductor, and general electronics markets to accelerate innovation to connect and secure the world. Learn more at Keysight Newsroom and www.keysight.com.

More from Keysight Technologies