December 12, 2018 The Corporate Social Responsibility Newswire

news by category

CSR News

Holy Land Principles Gain Momentum

SEC Gives Boost

Submitted by: Holy Land Principles, Inc

Categories: Socially Responsible Investing, Business Ethics

Posted: Feb 18, 2015 – 03:00 PM EST


CAPITOL HILL, WASHINGTON, Feb. 18 /CSRwire/ - The recent ruling by the SEC has put wind in the sails of the good ship, Holy Land Principles. That ruling stopped three major companies — Intel, GE and Corning —from excluding  Holy Land Principles resolutions from their 2015 Proxy Material.

Fr. Sean Mc Manus, President of the Capitol Hill-based Irish National Caucus, is the Irish-born priest who launched the successful Mac Bride Principles ( for Northern Ireland) in 1984 and  also the Holy Land Principles in 2012.

He explained: “ It’s a bit like déjà vu all over again. The companies doing business in Northern Ireland fought us tooth and nail, but eventually the American sense of fair play prevailed and 116 companies signed the Mac Bride Principles. But it took five years for the first company to sign the Mac Bride Principles. And, actually, we got Oxygen Biotherapeutics (now called Tenax Therapeutics ) to sign the Holy Land Principles within a couple of months.”


Fr. Mc Manus noted: “ When we launched the Mac Bride Principles, initially most people didn’t get it. Every political party and grouping in Ireland opposed the Principles. Famous big name Irish-American politicians resisted our campaign, but, as I said, justice prevailed, and now the Mac Bride Principles are universally seen to have played a key role in promoting fairness in Northern Ireland. I have no doubt the same will be true of the Holy Land Principles. Surely no American could argue that Irish Catholics in Northern Ireland deserve these Principles but Palestinian Christians and Palestinian Muslims do not? And surely no American company can claim that they support the Ruggie Principles if they oppose the Holy Land Principles, which are a perfect way to implement on the ground the Ruggie Principles? 


Fr. Mc Manus continued: “ It is important to note the SEC’s reasoning. In the case of Corning, the SEC rules: “Based on the information you have presented, it appears that Corning’s policies, practices and procedures do not compare favorably with the guidelines of the [Holy Land Principles] proposal and that Corning has not, therefore, substantially implemented the proposal.’

Both Intel and GE tried to make the case for exclusion as follows: ‘The [the Holy Land Principles] Proposal requires the Company’s board of directors to make all possible lawful efforts to implement the Holy Land Principles, including a principle, outlined in paragraph 7 of the Proposal, not to ‘accept subsidies, tax incentives or other benefits that lead to the direct advantage of one national, racial, ethnic or religious group over another. [Principle # 7] … As a result, by seeking to address the Company’s evaluation of subsidies, tax incentives or other benefits, the Proposal interferes with the Company’s ordinary business...’ 


Fr. Mc Manus concluded: “In other words, the two companies tried to argue that entering into a discriminatory situation, which by definition excludes other groups of employees, has nothing to do with fair employment and is just ‘ordinary business’. 

It is almost as if Intel and GE tried, so to speak, to stand in the doorway, declaring, segregation was ordinary business, while simultaneously claiming   that separate but equal is a valid  American fair employment principle. To their great credit the SEC would have none of it. In today’s cynical climate that sees little good in government, it’s nice to be able to say ‘ Three Cheers for the SEC, ’ a U.S government agency.”

For more information, please contact:

Sean Mc Manus President
Phone: 202-488-0107
Fax: 202-488-7537


Issuers of news releases and not csrwire are solely responsible for the accuracy of the content